Should You Hire a General Builder or Manage Your Own Trades for a House Renovation?
/ by Brendan Walsh / Finding Tradespeople

There is a version of this argument that gets trotted out all the time: cut out the main contractor, manage the trades yourself, save a fortune. And honestly, for the right person, that is true. But most people who try it for the first time do not save money. They lose it, slowly, in ways they never see coming.
A general builder takes a margin, usually somewhere between 15 and 25 per cent on top of trade costs. That is a real number and it stings when you are already stretched. So the logic of going direct to a plumber, an electrician, a plasterer, a tiler and sorting it yourself seems sound enough on paper. The problem is that you are not just paying for the work. You are paying for the coordination, the knowledge of which trade needs to finish before the next one can start, and the responsibility when things go wrong between them.
When you self-manage, that responsibility lands on you. If the plumber first-fixes and then the electrician needs to move something, one of them has to come back. Who pays for that? If the plasterer finishes and you have not ordered the skirting boards in time, you are paying a carpenter to come back for a half-day job at a full call-out rate. These small delays and revisits are where budgets quietly bleed out. Anyone who has been through a full kitchen renovation will recognise this immediately.
Experienced renovators handle it because they have built relationships with reliable tradespeople over years, they know the sequence cold, and they know how to have direct, specific conversations about what they need and when. That knowledge is genuinely worth something. It just takes time to earn it.
First-timers, almost without exception, underestimate how much time the coordination takes. We are talking about multiple phone calls a day during busy phases, being on site or reachable at short notice, chasing quotes, chasing start dates, chasing invoices. If you are working full-time, that overhead is brutal. And if you make one bad hire, someone who goes quiet mid-job or does work that needs redoing, the cost of sorting it out often wipes out everything you saved by not hiring a main contractor in the first place.
None of this means a general builder is always the better choice. A good one is worth every cent of the margin. A bad one, and there are plenty, is the worst of all worlds. So if you do go that route, ask around your area, look for someone who has done similar work recently, and talk to the people whose houses they have worked on. The vetting matters as much as the decision itself.
If this is your first big renovation, be honest with yourself about the time you have available. The margin you are trying to save can very easily become the most expensive part of the whole job.